Exploiting Illness: The Disinformation Campaign Following Scott Adams' Cancer Diagnosis

Key Findings:

• Adams' Statement: On May 19, 2025, Dilbert creator Scott Adams announced he has metastatic prostate cancer and a limited life expectancy. During his livestream, he explicitly stated, “People are going to say it’s because I got the COVID shot. There’s no indication that that makes a difference,” preemptively debunking any link between his cancer and the vaccine.
• Immediate Disinformation: Despite his clear denial, several X (formerly Twitter) accounts immediately began spreading claims that his cancer was caused by the COVID-19 vaccine.
• Manipulated Media: A key tactic involved sharing a selectively clipped 3-minute video from Adams' 40-minute announcement, decontextualizing his remarks to falsely suggest he blamed the vaccine. This is similar to what was done to a 2 year old video of Adam.
• Scientific Rebuttal: Adams' statements align with the broad scientific consensus that there is no evidence linking COVID-19 vaccines to cancer.

Who It Affects:

• Pharmaceutical Companies: Spread of disinformation around vaccines creates a stigma for pharmaceutical companies, painting them as villains in the public’s eye. This could disrupt business, complicate research and development efforts due to eroded public trust, discourage the public from participating in vaccine drives or clinical trials, and necessitate costly counter-misinformation campaigns.
• The Public: Exposed to false health information, which can fuel vaccine hesitancy, erode trust in public health messaging, cause undue anxiety, and lead to individuals making harmful health decisions based on falsehoods, potentially resulting in preventable illnesses or deaths.
• Scientific Integrity: The campaign undermines scientific consensus and the credibility of medical experts by promoting baseless claims, making it harder to communicate genuine scientific advancements and potentially leading to harassment or discrediting of researchers and healthcare professionals.
• Insurance Industry: Widespread health misinformation leading to poorer public health outcomes (e.g., lower vaccination rates resulting in more disease outbreaks) can increase claims and financial risks for insurers. This also extends to life and disability insurance sectors, as predicting long-term health trends becomes more challenging.
• Healthcare Systems & Providers: Increased vaccine hesitancy driven by misinformation can strain healthcare resources by leading to preventable outbreaks and more severe illnesses. Healthcare workers may also face increased distrust from patients, making it harder to provide care, and can become targets of harassment if they advocate for evidence-based medicine like vaccination.
• Technology & Social Media Platforms: These companies face ongoing scrutiny regarding their role in the spread of misinformation. Such incidents intensify pressure for more robust content moderation policies and enforcement, and can damage platform reputation if they are perceived as enabling the spread of harmful falsehoods.
• Scott Adams & His Family: The primary victims, facing a personal health crisis compounded by the malicious exploitation of his illness and misrepresentation of his words.

Why It Matters:

• Impact of Manipulated Media: The use of a clipped video highlights how easily decontextualized media can be used to create and spread false narratives effectively on social media. Adam's case shows that reputational harm is easy to spread. This highlights a growing risk of disinformation not only against individuals, but possibly companies as well.
• Persistence of Anti-Vaccine Narratives: It demonstrates the tenacity of anti-vaccine misinformation, which readily adapts to new events to reinforce debunked claims, even when directly contradicted by the individuals involved.
• Erosion of Trust: Such campaigns contribute to a broader erosion of trust in credible information sources. Businesses and industries pushing for vaccines face greater pushback for their products.

Trends & Developments:

• Rapid Dissemination on X: Accounts like @unhealthytruth, @true_explorer, @Pepe_Le_Pede3, and @MJTruthUltra quickly spread false claims, misquoting Adams and linking his cancer to the vaccine using inflammatory language and conspiracy theories.
• Tactics of Misrepresentation:
  
  • False Attribution: Directly stating Adams blamed the vaccine when he explicitly denied it.
  • Decontextualization: Using selectively edited video clips to alter the meaning of his statements.
  • Exploiting Past Commentary: Leveraging Adams' previous controversial statements on vaccines to lend false credibility to current claims.
  • Use of Anti-Vaccine Tropes: Employing terms like "turbo cancer" and pseudo-scientific jargon to create fear and suggest a cover-up.
• Influencer Amplification: The viral interaction with these false claims suggests amplification by a network of influencers and a receptive audience.

What We Anticipate & Opportunities:

• Continued Exploitation: Announcements from public figures and companies will likely continue to be targets for similar disinformation campaigns to fit the editor’s agenda.
• Need for Proactive Debunking: Public health bodies and fact-checkers must engage in rapid and clear debunking of such claims, amplifying the actual statements of the individuals involved and the scientific consensus.
• Platform Responsibility: Increased pressure on social media platforms like X to address the systematic spread of health misinformation and the accounts that persistently violate policies against it. This will hopefully assist in the spread of the truth and allow businesses to share information about their products to their audiences without any malicious attempts to twist them.
• Media Literacy: An opportunity to highlight the tactics of disinformation (e.g., manipulated video, decontextualization) to improve public media literacy and critical consumption of online content. Companies can use this as a case study to share with their current clients to be wary of where they get their information from.
• Focus on Source Verification: Emphasizing the importance of verifying information against primary sources (like Adams' full livestream) and credible news reports before sharing.

‍